Key Takeaways:
- Document collection efforts thoroughly throughout the year and establish clear criteria for determining when an invoice becomes uncollectible, as the IRS requires proof that you’ve taken reasonable steps to collect the debt
- Time your write-offs strategically before December 31st to maximize tax benefits for the current year, while ensuring proper accounting treatment based on whether you use cash or accrual accounting methods
- Implement automated AR management systems to track aging invoices, reduce write-offs by up to 4%, and maintain the documentation needed for tax compliance
Every law firm faces the uncomfortable reality of uncollectible invoices. Despite your best efforts, meticulous time tracking, and detailed billing, some clients simply won’t pay. The average collection rate for law firms in 2024 is 91%, leaving 9% of invoiced work unpaid—a significant hit to any firm’s bottom line. For mid-sized firms, this can represent hundreds of thousands of dollars in lost revenue each year.
As year-end approaches, law firms must make critical decisions about these outstanding receivables. Writing off bad debt isn’t just about cleaning up your books—it’s a strategic financial move that can reduce your tax burden while providing a clearer picture of your firm’s true financial position. But the process requires careful consideration of tax implications, accounting methods, and documentation requirements.
The good news? With proper planning and the right strategies, you can turn these inevitable losses into tax advantages while implementing systems to minimize future write-offs. This comprehensive guide walks you through the most effective approaches for writing off uncollectible client invoices at year-end, ensuring you maximize tax benefits while maintaining compliance with IRS requirements and accounting standards.
Understanding Bad Debt in Law Firms
Before diving into write-off strategies, it’s crucial to understand what constitutes bad debt for a law firm and when an invoice truly becomes uncollectible.
What Qualifies as Business Bad Debt
A debt becomes worthless when the surrounding facts and circumstances indicate there’s no reasonable expectation that the debt will be repaid. For law firms, this typically includes:
- Unpaid legal fees for services already rendered
- Advanced costs that clients promised to reimburse
- Court costs and filing fees paid on behalf of clients
- Expert witness fees and other case-related expenses
The key distinction is that these must be legitimate business debts owed to your firm, not personal loans or informal arrangements.
The Reality of Law Firm Collections
The statistics paint a sobering picture of accounts receivable challenges in the legal industry:
- On average, lawyers don’t collect 11 percent of the hours they bill clients
- The median amount of collection lockup that firms carry is 27 days
- On average, 4% of AR collections were written off as bad debt in 2019
These numbers underscore the importance of having a systematic approach to managing and eventually writing off uncollectible accounts.
When Does a Debt Become Uncollectible?
Determining when to write off an invoice requires careful judgment. To show that a debt is worthless, you must establish that you’ve taken reasonable steps to collect the debt. Signs that a debt may be uncollectible include:
- Client has filed for bankruptcy
- Business clients have ceased operations
- Individual clients have died or disappeared
- Multiple collection attempts have failed
- The cost of legal action exceeds the debt amount
- A court judgment would likely be uncollectible
Tax Implications of Writing Off Bad Debt
Understanding the tax treatment of bad debt write-offs is essential for maximizing their benefit to your firm. The rules differ significantly based on your accounting method and the nature of your practice.
Cash vs. Accrual Method Considerations
The accounting method your firm uses fundamentally affects how you handle bad debt:
Cash Method Accounting: If your firm uses cash basis accounting, you generally cannot deduct bad debts for unpaid invoices because you haven’t already included the amount they owed you in your firm’s gross income for the year. However, you can still deduct:
- Out-of-pocket expenses advanced for clients
- Court costs and filing fees you paid
- Any other actual cash outlays that won’t be reimbursed
Accrual Method Accounting: Firms using accrual accounting have more opportunities for bad debt deductions because they recognize income when earned, not when collected. A basis in debt occurs when you’ve already included the amount they owed you in your firm’s gross income for the year.
IRS Requirements for Deductibility
To claim a bad debt deduction, you must meet several IRS requirements:
- Bona Fide Debt: The debt must be a bona fide debt owed to you. You’ll need to have proof of services rendered, the payment agreed upon, and failure on the client’s part to deliver payment
- Basis in the Debt: You must have already included the amount in income (for accrual basis) or actually paid out cash (for expenses)
- Reasonable Collection Efforts: The IRS requires documentation showing you’ve attempted to collect
- Timing: You may take the deduction only in the year the debt becomes worthless. You don’t have to wait until a debt is due to determine that it’s worthless
Business vs. Non-Business Bad Debts
For law firms, virtually all client-related bad debts qualify as business bad debts, which is advantageous because:
- Business bad debts are fully deductible as ordinary business expenses
- They can offset ordinary income dollar-for-dollar
- No capital loss limitations apply
Step-by-Step Process for Year-End Write-Offs
Successfully writing off uncollectible invoices requires a systematic approach that ensures compliance while maximizing tax benefits.
Step 1: Conduct a Comprehensive AR Review
Begin your year-end write-off process by conducting a thorough review of all outstanding receivables:
Age Your Accounts Receivable
- Generate an aging report showing all invoices by age brackets (30, 60, 90, 120+ days)
- The median amount of collection lockup that firms carry is 27 days, so anything beyond 90 days deserves scrutiny
- Flag accounts that have shown no payment activity in the past six months
Review Client Communication History
- Document all collection attempts for each overdue account
- Note any promises to pay that weren’t fulfilled
- Identify clients who have become unresponsive
Step 2: Document Collection Efforts Thoroughly
Proper documentation is crucial for IRS compliance. Keep all documentation of bad debt situations. Unpaid invoices, collection letters, credit reports, anything that documents the activities. Your documentation should include:
- Original engagement letters and fee agreements
- All invoices sent to the client
- Email and letter correspondence regarding payment
- Phone call logs with dates and discussion summaries
- Any payment plans proposed or attempted
- Collection agency reports (if applicable)
- Court filings or judgments
Step 3: Make the Worthlessness Determination
For each potentially uncollectible account, evaluate whether it meets the criteria for worthlessness:
Objective Indicators:
- Bankruptcy filing documentation
- Death certificates
- Business closure notices
- Returned mail marked “undeliverable”
- Unsuccessful legal judgments
Subjective Factors:
- Length of time invoice has been outstanding
- Client’s financial condition (if known)
- Cost-benefit analysis of further collection efforts
- Historical payment patterns
Document your reasoning for each determination. This creates an audit trail if the IRS questions your deductions.
Step 4: Calculate the Write-Off Amount
Determine the exact amount to write off for each account:
- For accrual basis firms: Include the full invoiced amount
- For cash basis firms: Only include actual out-of-pocket expenses
- Mixed scenarios: Separate fees from reimbursable expenses
Remember to exclude any amounts already written off in previous years or any partial payments received.
Step 5: Execute the Accounting Entries
The mechanics of recording the write-off depend on your accounting system:
Direct Write-Off Method:
- Debit: Bad Debt Expense
- Credit: Accounts Receivable
Allowance Method (for firms maintaining bad debt reserves):
- Debit: Allowance for Doubtful Accounts
- Credit: Accounts Receivable
Modern accounting software can automate these entries while maintaining proper documentation for tax purposes.
Timing Strategies for Maximum Tax Benefit
The timing of your bad debt write-offs can significantly impact their tax benefit. Strategic planning around year-end can optimize your firm’s tax position.
Why December 31st Matters
For any accounts deemed uncollectible, write them off as of December 31 to ensure the deduction applies to the current tax year. This timing is critical because:
- Deductions taken this year reduce current tax liability
- Delaying write-offs pushes tax benefits into the future
- Cash flow benefits from reduced tax payments come sooner
Accelerating Write-Offs for Tax Planning
If your firm anticipates higher income this year compared to next year, accelerating bad debt write-offs can provide valuable tax relief:
Current Year High Income Scenarios:
- Exceptional year with unusually high revenues
- One-time contingency fee windfalls
- Large case settlements received
- Partner buyouts or retirements creating taxable events
In these situations, maximizing current-year deductions through aggressive but justified write-offs can significantly reduce tax burden.
Coordination with Other Year-End Tax Strategies
Bad debt write-offs should be considered alongside other year-end tax planning:
- Equipment purchases under Section 179
- Retirement plan contributions
- Bonus payments to employees
- Charitable contributions
- Operating expense prepayments
Work with your tax advisor to optimize the mix of deductions for your firm’s specific situation.
Documentation Best Practices
Thorough documentation isn’t just good practice—it’s essential for defending your bad debt deductions if questioned by the IRS.
Creating an Audit Trail
Build a comprehensive file for each written-off account that includes:
Client Information:
- Complete contact information
- Engagement letter or retainer agreement
- All invoices and billing statements
- Payment history (including partial payments)
Collection Efforts:
- Copies of all demand letters
- Email correspondence
- Phone call logs with dates and notes
- Collection agency agreements and reports
- Legal action documentation
Worthlessness Determination:
- Written analysis of why the debt is uncollectible
- Supporting evidence (bankruptcy filings, death certificates, etc.)
- Date worthlessness was determined
- Approval by appropriate firm authority
IRS Requirements and Compliance
The IRS may scrutinize bad debt deductions, especially large write-offs. The taxpayer must make (and document) all reasonable efforts to collect the debt. However, they are not required to take legal action if the facts and circumstances clearly establish that such action would be futile.
Key compliance considerations:
- Maintain records for at least seven years
- Be prepared to show the business purpose of the debt
- Document why further collection efforts would be futile
- Keep evidence of the debt’s existence and validity
Using Technology for Documentation
Legal practice management software can streamline documentation by:
- Automatically tracking client communications
- Maintaining payment history records
- Generating aging reports
- Creating audit trails for all transactions
- Storing documents electronically for easy retrieval
Alternative Strategies Before Writing Off
Before permanently writing off a debt, consider these alternative approaches that might recover some value:
Payment Plans and Settlements
Debt Restructuring: This involves renegotiating the terms of the debt with the debtor to make it more manageable and increase the likelihood of repayment. Options include:
- Extended payment plans spreading the balance over months
- Reduced settlements accepting less than full amount
- Work-for-credit arrangements where clients provide services
- Asset transfers accepting property in lieu of payment
Even partial recovery is better than a complete write-off, and the client relationship may be preserved.
Collection Agencies and Legal Action
Before writing off larger debts, evaluate whether third-party collection efforts make sense:
Collection Agencies:
- Typically charge 25-50% of amounts collected
- May be effective for debts under $10,000
- Preserve your firm’s relationship with the client
- Handle the time-consuming follow-up process
Legal Action:
- Consider for larger debts where assets exist
- Factor in the cost of litigation
- Evaluate collectibility of any judgment
- May be necessary to establish worthlessness for tax purposes
Factoring and Sale of Receivables
Some firms sell their receivables to factoring companies:
- Immediate cash for 70-90% of invoice value
- Transfer collection risk to the factor
- Useful for cash flow management
- May preserve client relationships
While you’ll receive less than face value, this can be preferable to a complete write-off.
Implementing Systems to Reduce Future Write-Offs
The best bad debt is the one you never incur. Implementing robust systems can dramatically reduce future write-offs.
Improved Billing and Collection Processes
Firms that use payment plans collect 49 percent more monthly revenue per lawyer, demonstrating the power of flexible payment options. Key improvements include:
Billing Best Practices:
- Send invoices immediately upon work completion
- Provide detailed, clear descriptions of services
- Offer multiple payment methods
- Include payment terms prominently
Collection Optimization:
- Incorrect invoices are responsible for a reported 61% of late payments
- Implement automated payment reminders
- Follow up within 10 days of due date
- Escalate collection efforts systematically
Client Screening and Credit Policies
Preventing bad debt starts with client selection:
Initial Screening:
- Run credit checks on business clients
- Request retainers for new clients
- Verify ability to pay before engagement
- Check references from other professionals
Ongoing Monitoring:
- Review account status regularly
- Address payment issues early
- Stop work when accounts become severely delinquent
- Document all payment discussions
Regular AR Monitoring
If your law firm’s collection rate is less than 90%, the strategies below can help improve your accounts receivable process:
- Review AR aging weekly
- Calculate collection rates monthly
- Track write-off trends by practice area
- Identify problem accounts early
- Set collection goals and monitor progress
Automated reporting tools can provide real-time visibility into collection metrics.
Leveraging Technology
Firms that offer online payment options get paid more than twice as fast as those that don’t. Technology solutions that reduce write-offs include:
- Online payment portals for client convenience
- Automated billing software reducing errors
- Payment plan management systems
- Collections tracking and reporting
- Client portal access for invoice review
Common Pitfalls to Avoid
Even well-intentioned firms make mistakes when writing off bad debt. Avoid these common pitfalls:
Inadequate Documentation
The most common mistake is insufficient documentation of collection efforts. The IRS can disallow deductions if you can’t prove:
- The debt existed
- You attempted collection
- The debt became worthless in the year claimed
Always err on the side of over-documentation.
Premature Write-Offs
Writing off debts too quickly can cost you in two ways:
- Lost opportunity for collection
- Potential IRS challenge to the deduction
There isn’t a simple answer to this question. Businesses vary in their operations and have different criteria for when they should write off bad debt. Develop clear, consistent criteria for your firm.
Ignoring Partial Worthlessness
Your debt needs to be considered at least partially worthless. Don’t wait for total worthlessness if partial write-off is justified:
- Client disputes specific charges
- Partial payment is all that’s possible
- Settlement negotiations indicate reduced recovery
Mixing Personal and Business Debts
Keep strict separation between:
- Firm receivables and personal loans to clients
- Business expenses and personal expenditures
- Client trust accounts and operating accounts
Commingling can jeopardize deductions and create ethical issues.
Recovery of Previously Written-Off Debts
Occasionally, clients pay debts after you’ve written them off. Proper handling of these recoveries is essential for tax compliance.
Tax Treatment of Recovered Debts
The amount recovered is considered gross income to the extent you claimed the debt as a deduction in the previous tax year, which reduced your taxable income as per the tax benefit rule.
If you recover a debt written off in a prior year:
- Report the recovery as income in the year received
- Only include the amount that provided a tax benefit
- No need to amend prior year returns
Documentation needed:
- Original write-off documentation
- Payment receipt and deposit records
- Calculation of tax benefit received
- Current year income recognition
Accounting for Recoveries
In a few rare cases, you’ll write off a debt as uncollectible only to have the customer pay it after you’ve already written it off. When this happens:
- Reverse the write-off entry (partially or fully)
- Record the payment as usual
- Recognize income if required for tax purposes
- Update client records to reflect payment
Modern billing software can automate these adjustments while maintaining proper audit trails.
Working with Tax Professionals
Given the complexity of bad debt deductions, working with qualified tax professionals is essential.
When to Consult Your CPA
Engage your tax advisor when:
- Writing off significant amounts (over $50,000)
- Dealing with complex client situations
- Changing accounting methods
- Planning major year-end tax strategies
- Facing IRS inquiries about previous write-offs
Coordinating with Your Bookkeeper
Ensure your bookkeeping team:
- Understands your write-off policies
- Maintains proper documentation
- Codes transactions correctly
- Generates required reports timely
- Coordinates with tax preparers
Year-End Planning Sessions
Schedule strategic planning sessions in November to:
- Review potential write-offs
- Analyze tax implications
- Coordinate with other tax strategies
- Ensure documentation is complete
- Execute write-offs before year-end
Technology Solutions for AR Management
Modern technology can transform how firms manage accounts receivable and minimize write-offs.
Benefits of Automated AR Systems
91% of mid-sized firms with fully automated AR systems report increased savings, cash flow, and growth. Key benefits include:
- Real-time visibility into account status
- Automated reminders reducing collection time
- Accurate aging reports for decision-making
- Integrated payment processing improving collection rates
- Comprehensive documentation for tax compliance
Essential Features to Look For
When evaluating AR management technology, prioritize:
Collection Management:
- Automated payment reminders
- Escalation workflows
- Payment plan management
- Client portal access
Reporting and Analytics:
- Real-time AR aging reports
- Collection rate tracking
- Write-off trend analysis
- Partner/practice area performance
Integration Capabilities:
- Accounting software synchronization
- Payment processor connectivity
- Document management integration
- Tax preparation software compatibility
ROI of AR Technology
75% of finance leaders say accounts receivable has become more strategic over the past 12-24 months. The return on investment includes:
- Reduced write-offs (typically 20-40% improvement)
- Faster collections (often 50% reduction in DSO)
- Lower administrative costs
- Better client satisfaction
- Improved cash flow predictability
Conclusion
Writing off uncollectible client invoices at year-end is both a necessary housekeeping task and a strategic opportunity for law firms. While no firm wants to face bad debt, properly managing and documenting these write-offs can provide significant tax benefits while cleaning up your financial statements.
The key to success lies in preparation and systematic execution. By maintaining thorough documentation throughout the year, implementing robust collection processes, and strategically timing your write-offs, you can maximize tax benefits while minimizing future bad debt. Remember that you may take the deduction only in the year the debt becomes worthless, making year-end planning crucial.
Looking forward, the best strategy is prevention. 91% of mid-sized firms with fully automated AR systems report increased savings, cash flow, and growth. By investing in proper technology and processes, firms can reduce write-offs while improving overall financial health.
As you approach year-end, take time to thoroughly review your accounts receivable, document your collection efforts, and work with your tax professionals to optimize your write-off strategy. The effort you invest now will pay dividends in reduced tax liability and cleaner books for the coming year.
Ready to transform your accounts receivable management and reduce future write-offs? Discover how LeanLaw’s automated billing and collection tools can help you maintain better documentation, improve collection rates, and streamline your year-end write-off process.
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: Can law firms using cash accounting write off unpaid invoices? A: Generally no. Cash basis firms cannot deduct unpaid invoices because they never recognized the income. However, they can write off actual cash expenditures made on behalf of clients, such as filing fees, expert witness costs, or other expenses that won’t be reimbursed.
Q: How long should we attempt collection before writing off an invoice? A: While there’s no fixed timeline, most firms consider write-offs after 120-180 days of non-payment, provided they’ve documented reasonable collection efforts. The key is showing the IRS that further collection attempts would be futile.
Q: Do we need to sue a client before writing off their debt? A: No. It’s not necessary to go to court if you can show that a judgment from the court would be uncollectible. Document why legal action would be futile, such as the client’s insolvency or the cost exceeding the debt amount.
Q: What documentation does the IRS require for bad debt deductions? A: The IRS requires proof of the debt’s existence (invoices, engagement letters), evidence of collection attempts (letters, emails, phone logs), and documentation supporting worthlessness (bankruptcy filings, returned mail, credit reports). Keep all records for at least seven years.
Q: Can we write off a portion of an invoice if the client disputes only certain charges? A: Yes. Your debt needs to be considered at least partially worthless. You can write off disputed portions while continuing to pursue undisputed amounts, provided you document the partial worthlessness determination.
Q: How do we handle bad debt recoveries in future years? A: The amount recovered is considered gross income to the extent you claimed the debt as a deduction in the previous tax year. Report recoveries as income in the year received, but only to the extent they provided a previous tax benefit.
Q: Should we use the direct write-off method or maintain an allowance for doubtful accounts? A: This depends on your firm’s size and accounting sophistication. Larger firms often maintain allowances for more accurate financial reporting, while smaller firms may use direct write-offs for simplicity. Consult your accountant for the best approach for your firm.
Q: Can partners personally deduct law firm bad debts? A: Only if the partner personally guaranteed the debt or made personal expenditures. Generally, firm bad debts are deducted at the entity level and flow through to partners based on their ownership percentage.
Q: What’s the difference between writing off bad debt and forgiving debt? A: Writing off bad debt is an internal accounting action for uncollectible amounts. Debt forgiveness is formally releasing the client from obligation, which may trigger tax consequences for the client (cancelled debt income) and requires Form 1099-C if over $600.
Q: How can we reduce our bad debt write-offs going forward? A: Key strategies include requiring retainers, running credit checks, offering payment plans (firms that use payment plans collect 49 percent more monthly revenue per lawyer), accepting online payments, and implementing automated reminder systems. Regular AR monitoring and early intervention are also crucial.
Sources
- Internal Revenue Service. “Topic No. 453, Bad Debt Deduction.” IRS.gov.
- Bloomberg Tax. “Deducting Business Bad Debt.” March 20, 2025.
- Clio. “Key Performance Indicators for Law Firms.” 2024.
- Clio. “Best Practices for Faster Accounts Receivable Collections.” December 3, 2024.
- Law Firm Velocity. “Maximizing Law Firm Utilization, Realization, and Collection Rates.” 2024.
- HighRadius. “What Is Bad Debt Write Off? Everything You Need To Know.” March 8, 2024.
- Attorney at Work. “Small Firm Hourly Rates by State and Practice Area.” October 24, 2024.
- LawRank. “Top Law Firm Statistics of 2024.” May 28, 2024.
- Upflow. “13 Accounts Receivable Stats You Should Know in 2024.” June 18, 2024.
- Clio. “Year-End Law Firm Financial Best Practices for 2025.” May 16, 2025.
- Cornell University. “Writing Off Uncollectable Receivables.” Division of Financial Services.
- Wolters Kluwer. “Allowance for Uncollectible Accounts (Bad Debt).” March 12, 2022.
- LawPay. “9 Steps to Better Law Firm Accounts Receivable Management.” 2024.
- Resolve Pay. “When to Write-off Bad Debt.” April 4, 2025.
- CosmoLex. “Can our law firm write off bad debts?” November 3, 2024.
